| Front page | News and Noticeboard | A New Dawn |
Time for Action
Margaret Lee and Jane Turner consider where we can all do more to support survivors of sexual abuse | To go back to Ichthus index, close this window
| ||
In response to the Time for Action Report, the Advisory Group for Child Protection in the Nottingham and Derby District felt it appropriate to offer training to local preachers to raise awareness about survivors of sexual abuse and consider some of the implications for worship in our churches.
We began by considering the model developed by Roland Summit, an American psychiatrist. Although we refer to abusers as "he", it is important to remember that a small proportion of children are abused by women. We are also writing about victims of either gender. Sexually abused children find it hard to tell anyone about the abuse. Summit highlighted key factors which explain this. Secrecy underpins all sexual abuse. It is imperative to the abuser not to be found out and so he works hard to ensure the child's silence. The core is to bring the child to a point where he or she believes the responsibility for the abuse, and keeping the secret, is theirs. Often the child is made, by threats, to anticipate the consequences of telling. Sometimes the child is made to feel special and is caught in a seductive web by the abuser. A sense of helplessness follows the secrecy. Societal values emphasise the omnipotence of adults over children. Adults are people whom children are expected to believe and obey. Children are taught to be wary of strangers but this offers little protection when most abuse is perpetrated by known and trusted adults. Children have no mandate to deal with this. They are dependent and need to believe in the intrinsic goodness of adults. The alternative is to fear abandonment. Therefore, the child must take the burden of blame on to their own shoulders believing they, not the adult, are bad. Herein lies the source of the low self esteem which haunts so many survivors.
We can now understand more easily why a child who manages to disclose does so in a tentative, disjointed and, sometimes, unconvincing way. The abuser may be well loved and respected by others. The abuse may have created difficulties in the child's behaviour, so they are already regarded as difficult and unreliable. The child will assume no one will believe them. Sometimes allegations are retracted by the child. This can be quite a normal response when the child sees the effect of their disclosure. He or she will then remember all the means by which the abuser maintained their silence previously and so the power is reinforced. After considering how abuse affects survivors, we moved on to think about church life in relation to their experiences.
Survivors are not necessarily any more comfortable with a maternal image of God because they may experience anger towards mothers for not protecting them. In the Bible males represent power and women, generally, are subordinate and in the background. If their sexual side is acknowledged at all, it is often in terms of sinfulness whether real or implied. For example Eve is portrayed as a seductress who leads Adam astray. There is Rehab the prostitute, Jezebel the scheming woman, and the woman at the well. Although Jesus makes no criticism, this last story is often told and received in such a way as to cast doubt on her moral standards. The depiction of men as the figures of authority is probably a reasonable reflection of society at the time but can be used by an abuser as justification for his actions since females appear less worth of attention (or perhaps worthless). But it is not only women who suffer from this image. If to be male is to be strong and powerful, how do male victims of abuse feel if that power is taken away by someone stronger? Survivors of abuse may feel that God is absent from the situation because their prayers for the abuse to stop appear not to be answered. If the abuse has happened within the church, survivors may find it difficult to believe in God at all. Sometimes the Church has responded to a survivor's efforts to seek support by excluding them from the church community for sinfulness and "sexual perversion" after they have confided in a priest. A survivor's experience of abuse can leave them feeling suicidal and to be told that these feelings are sinful is less than helpful. So how can survivors cope with coming to church in these circumstances? One way is to adapt their beliefs and focus on the areas they can cope with, for example, accepting the existence of God but not being able to call him Lord or pray to him. We need to recognise emotional pain and allow people to be angry with God. When we talk about suffering we tend to focus on disaster, illness and disability. Domestic violence and abuse rarely appear, perhaps because we still cling to the traditional image of the family. Is it safer to concentrate on broader issues that are not so close to home? We considered what the term "family worship" might represent to a survivor of sexual abuse. If it means attended by families, not everyone has a family and many children do not have a stable family background. If it means the church family then we need to remember that some people's experience of family is an abusive one.
We ended our session by having small groups which considered the implications for Sermons and Bible readings, Prayer and Hymns, and Childrens' Work. We aired the subjects and started some discussion. Some of the points raised by the small groups were:
Margaret Lee is a member of the Ripley Circuit and is a Social Worker in a specialist team offering therapeutic help to children and parents who have experienced sexual abuse. Jane Turner is a member of the Derby East Circuit and is a Social Worker with a background in child protection work and currently working in a Social Services Training Department. Both are members of the Nottingham and Derby District Advisory Group for Child Protection. "Individuals who have been abused by their fathers may find it difficult to accept God as father because they have known a father who has betrayed them and abused his position of trust and authority."
Sources: "Time for Action" Sexual Abuse, the Churches and a new dawn for Survivors - £7.95 from CTBI, reference CT140 from MPH Roland Summit The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome in Child Abuse and Neglect Vol, 7 pp 177 193 1983 Patrick Parkinson Child Sexual Abuse and the Churches Published by Hodder and Stoughton 1997.
| |||